The Toyota Highlander has been a popular choice for families and outdoor enthusiasts alike, thanks to its spacious interior, reliable performance, and excellent safety features. In 2016 and 2017, the Highlander continued to impress with its blend of comfort, utility, and style.
In this comparison, we’ll delve into the key differences between the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlander models. We’ll explore factors such as exterior design, interior features, engine performance, fuel economy, and safety features.
By understanding the nuances between these two model years, you can make an informed decision when purchasing a used Toyota Highlander.
Table of Contents
A Subtle Shift: Unpacking the Exterior Styling of the 2016 vs 2017 Toyota Highlanders
While both the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlanders share the same underlying platform and overall design ethos, subtle differences in their exterior styling set them apart. These changes, though perhaps not drastic, contribute to the evolution of the Highlander’s visual identity. Let’s delve into the specifics and explore the nuances of their exterior design.
Overall Styling: A Gentle Evolution
The 2016 Toyota Highlander presented a modern and refined exterior design that was well-received by the market. Its front fascia featured a prominent grille, angular headlights, and a sculpted bumper, exuding a sense of strength and sophistication. Moving to the side, its body lines were smooth and flowing, with a strong shoulder line that added to its robust appearance.
The rear of the 2016 model is characterised by wraparound taillights and a subtle rear spoiler. In 2017, the Highlander received a mild refresh, which included some subtle tweaks to its exterior styling. The front grille was redesigned to be more prominent, with new horizontal slats that provided a more assertive look.
The headlights were also updated with new LED daytime running lights, which gave the front end a more contemporary feel. The rear remained largely unchanged, with only minor adjustments to the taillight design and bumper.
Front Fascia: The Devil in the Details
One of the most noticeable differences between the two model years is the design of the front fascia. The 2016 Highlander has a more understated grille design, with horizontal chrome bars and a subtle Toyota badge. This grille blends into the overall design of the front end. The 2017 model features a redesigned grille that has a more aggressive appearance.
This new grille extends further down the bumper and has a more angular and detailed design. The headlights on the 2017 model also have a more modern look, with distinctive LED daytime running lights that were not available on the 2016 model. These subtle changes provide the 2017 model with a more refined and up-to-date look.
Trim Levels and Packages: A Range of Visual Options
Both the 2016 and 2017 Highlanders were available in a range of trim levels, each offering different features and styling cues. The base models of both years feature more basic styling elements. However, as you move up the trim levels, such as the LE, XLE, and Limited grades, you start to find more premium features, including chrome accents, upgraded alloy wheels and different front grille designs.
Certain packages, such as the appearance packages, could add unique features such as body kits and upgraded wheels. These visual packages gave buyers more control of the exterior of their new vehicle. It is important to check the individual models to ensure that all the desired features are included.
Wheel Options: A Foundation of Style
The wheel options also vary between the two models and trim levels. The base models of both years have smaller steel wheels with plastic wheel covers. Upgraded models feature larger alloy wheels in a variety of different designs. The 2017 model featured a new wheel design, which helped to differentiate it further from the 2016 model.
It is important to note that wheel sizes typically range between 18″ and 19″, depending on the trim. The wheel design can have a considerable impact on the overall aesthetic of the vehicle, with some buyers prioritising a more sporty look, whilst others may want something more refined and traditional.
Subtle but Significant: The Overall Impact
While the changes to the exterior styling of the 2017 Toyota Highlander may not be considered drastic, they do have a notable impact on its overall appearance. The new front fascia, with its more prominent grille and updated headlights, gives the 2017 model a more contemporary and aggressive look.
These subtle tweaks, combined with the different wheel options and trim levels, provide the 2017 model with a fresh and refined look compared to the slightly more subtle and rounded design of the 2016 model. Overall, both models offer a sleek design that is ideal for buyers who are looking for something visually pleasing and practical.
Stepping Inside: Comparing Interior Design and Features
The interior of any vehicle is where occupants spend most of their time. When considering a family-focused SUV like the Toyota Highlander, the cabin design, features, and comfort levels become paramount. While both the 2016 and 2017 models share the same overall platform, subtle changes and updates to technology and materials mark important distinctions. Let’s take a closer look inside.
Cabin Layout and Design: Subtle Refinements
The overall cabin layout of the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlanders is largely similar. Both models offer a spacious three-row interior that comfortably seats up to eight passengers. The dashboard design is functional, with a clean and intuitive layout. However, the 2017 model did introduce some refinements that enhance the user experience.
The centre console design was slightly tweaked for improved ergonomics and access to controls, and the materials used throughout the cabin were also subject to small improvements, giving a slight uplift in premium feel. The design of both cabins reflects the practical and family-focused intentions of the car, with durability and ease of use being key factors in the design.
Infotainment and Technology: A Key Upgrade
One of the biggest changes between the 2016 and 2017 models can be found in the infotainment systems. The 2016 Toyota Highlander used Toyota’s older Entune system, with a touchscreen display, available in either a 6.1-inch or an 8-inch display, depending on the trim level. This system offered basic features, such as navigation, Bluetooth connectivity, and USB integration.
The 2017 model, however, benefited from an updated version of the Entune system. This update improved the user interface, with faster response times, a more modern design, and a slightly more user-friendly menu system. While both models share the same general interface and features, the upgraded system in the 2017 model offers a better experience. The improvements extended to other areas of technology as well, with better connectivity features.
Seating and Comfort: Family-Focused Design
Both the 2016 and 2017 Highlanders are designed with family comfort in mind. The front seats offer ample space and support. The second-row seats are generally comfortable, with options for bench or captain’s chairs, depending on the trim level and buyer preference. The third-row seats, while adequate for smaller adults or children, offer less space compared to the front and second rows.
Both models offer a high-quality feel to the materials used throughout the cabin and offer plenty of space for the driver and passenger. The comfort levels are a focus of the car’s design and are very good for a large 7 or 8-seater SUV.
Cargo Space and Versatility: Practicality is Key
When it comes to cargo space, both the 2016 and 2017 Highlanders offer a similar experience. With all three rows of seats in place, the cargo area is limited, but it is still practical for a weekly shop or for smaller luggage. Folding down the third-row seats opens up a more sizeable space while folding down the second-row seats creates a massive area that can be used to carry larger items.
The seats fold down flat, allowing owners to carry long and large objects with ease. Both models have a hidden storage compartment underneath the rear floor, which allows items to be stowed away from prying eyes. This practicality is a key feature of the car’s design.
Additional Interior Features
Beyond the key areas of infotainment, seating, and storage, both Highlanders boast a number of additional features. Automatic climate control is a standard feature, offering control of the temperature and airflow throughout the cabin, and is an essential comfort element for vehicles.
A multi-function steering wheel with audio controls is another common feature that improves the user experience when driving. The higher trim levels often include leather upholstery, heated seats, and a sunroof, among other features. Both models offer high levels of comfort and convenience for the driver and the passengers.
Power Under the Bonnet: A Look at Performance and Dynamics
The Toyota Highlander, whether the 2016 or 2017 model, is designed to provide a smooth and reliable driving experience. Yet subtle differences in engine options, transmissions, and overall tuning result in unique performance characteristics between these model years. Understanding these nuances can help you make a more informed decision about which is the better choice for you. Let’s explore the key elements of their performance and driving dynamics.
Engine Choices: Four Cylinders and a Powerful V6
The 2016 Toyota Highlander offered two primary engine options: a 2.7-litre four-cylinder engine and a more potent 3.5-litre V6. The four-cylinder provided a more affordable entry point and was generally adequate for day-to-day driving, producing around 185 horsepower.
However, for those looking for a stronger and more confident engine option, the 3.5-litre V6 was always the preferred choice. This engine delivered around 270 horsepower with smooth acceleration and added confidence for towing and carrying heavier loads. The 2017 Toyota Highlander retained the 2.7-litre four-cylinder but introduced a heavily updated 3.5-litre V6 engine. This revised V6 engine offered more power and improved fuel economy, outputting around 295 horsepower.
This significant engine upgrade for the 2017 model made a noticeable difference in performance and overall driving experience. This revised engine was one of the most significant upgrades for the 2017 model year.
Transmission Options: The Gearbox Matters
Transmission choices also vary slightly between the two model years. The 2016 model was equipped with a 6-speed automatic transmission, which was well-matched to both the four-cylinder and the V6 engine. This transmission provided smooth gear changes and contributed to the Highlander’s comfortable driving experience.
The 2017 Highlander retained the 6-speed transmission for models equipped with the four-cylinder engine. However, the V6 was paired with an all-new 8-speed automatic transmission. This new 8-speed transmission improved fuel economy and provided smoother, faster shifts. The 8-speed automatic transmission was another key component of the performance upgrade for the 2017 model.
Handling and Ride Quality: A Smooth and Controlled Ride
Both the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlanders are known for their comfortable and well-controlled ride. The suspension is tuned to provide a good balance of comfort and stability, making both models a good option for long journeys. The steering feels light and precise, making it easy to manoeuvre the car in everyday driving situations.
However, the 2017 model, with its upgraded engine and transmission, does feel slightly more responsive and agile than the 2016 version. The revised V6 engine and the 8-speed transmission provide a more engaging driving experience overall. The chassis and suspension system did not see any significant upgrades between the two model years.
Fuel Economy: A Balancing Act
Fuel economy is often a major consideration for SUV buyers. The 2016 Toyota Highlander offered reasonable fuel consumption for its class, with the 3.5-litre V6 generally giving around 20 mpg (miles per gallon) combined and the 4-cylinder achieving slightly better fuel economy, often in the region of 22 mpg combined. The 2017 Toyota Highlander saw a noticeable improvement in fuel economy from the revised 3.5 litre V6, often achieving around 23 mpg combined, depending on driving conditions.
The updated 8-speed automatic transmission assisted in this fuel saving. However, the fuel economy figures for both models are similar to a four-cylinder engine model, with little to no change. This made the 2017 model a better option in general, given the extra power and the improved fuel economy.
Safety First: Analysing Protection and Driver Assistance
When it comes to family SUVs, safety is paramount. The Toyota Highlander, in both its 2016 and 2017 iterations, is designed with safety as a core priority. However, subtle differences in their safety features and the availability of advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) can influence the overall protection offered. Let’s delve into the details of the safety equipment and crash test performance of these two models.
Standard Safety Features: A Strong Foundation
Both the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlander models come equipped with a comprehensive suite of standard safety features. These include an anti-lock braking system (ABS), electronic stability control, traction control, and a full complement of airbags. The airbag system includes front, side, and curtain airbags designed to protect occupants in the event of a collision.
Both models also benefit from a rearview camera, which greatly assists when reversing. This safety equipment forms a strong basis for the protection of passengers and is a key aspect when choosing a reliable family SUV. Toyota’s commitment to safety is well documented, and both model years reflect this well.
Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS): The Modern Edge
The availability of advanced driver assistance systems represents a key difference between the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlander. The 2016 model offered some ADAS features, but they were not as comprehensive or readily available as in the newer model. The 2017 Toyota Highlander saw the introduction of the “Toyota Safety Sense P” (TSS-P) as standard equipment on most trims.
This suite of advanced safety technologies included a pre-collision system with pedestrian detection, lane departure alert with steering assist, dynamic radar cruise control, and automatic high-beam headlights. These systems work to monitor the road and driver inputs to help prevent collisions, keeping drivers and passengers safe on the road. The availability of TSS-P made a very clear difference to the overall safety features offered by the newer model.
Understanding Key ADAS Features:
- Pre-Collision System with Pedestrian Detection: This system uses radar and cameras to detect vehicles and pedestrians in front of the car. If a collision risk is detected, the system will provide warnings and can automatically apply the brakes to help avoid or mitigate an impact.
- Lane Departure Alert with Steering Assist: This feature monitors lane markings and provides warnings if the car begins to drift out of its lane. If the driver does not respond, the system can provide steering input to help keep the car in its lane.
- Dynamic Radar Cruise Control: This adaptive cruise control system automatically adjusts the car’s speed to maintain a set distance from the vehicle ahead. It can help reduce driver fatigue on long journeys.
- Automatic High Beam Headlights: This system automatically adjusts the high beam headlights based on the presence of oncoming traffic, improving visibility at night.
Crash Test Ratings: The Official Verdict
Both the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlander models received high safety ratings from reputable organisations such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). However, the 2017 model often scored slightly better due to the inclusion of advanced safety features.
The IIHS awarded the 2017 Highlander a “Top Safety Pick+” rating, while the 2016 model received the “Top Safety Pick” rating. These ratings show how important advanced safety features are in keeping occupants as safe as possible in a collision. These ratings also showed that the 2017 model had improved from the previous model.
The Value of Added Safety
The comprehensive suite of safety features, particularly the standard inclusion of Toyota Safety Sense P in the 2017 model, gives it a notable advantage over the 2016 model. While both models provide a high level of safety, the 2017 Toyota Highlander comes equipped with more modern safety technology that assists in the prevention of an accident happening in the first place. These systems add to the overall protection of the occupants and enhance the driving experience of the car.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between the 2016 and 2017 Toyota Highlander depends on your priorities. The 2017 model offers a significant advantage with its updated engine, transmission, and advanced safety features, making it the better all-around choice. However, the 2016 model remains a solid, reliable option for those on a tighter budget. Test drive both to see which suits you best.