The BMW 528i vs 535i are two models within the BMW 5 Series, each offering a unique driving experience while sharing much of the same design, technology, and engineering principles. However, these two models have distinct differences in performance, features, and pricing, making them suitable for different drivers. In this article, we will comprehensively compare the BMW 528i and the BMW 535i, looking at their engine specifications, performance metrics, design features, technology, and overall driving experience.
Table of Contents
Overview of the BMW 5 Series
Before delving into the specifics of the 528i and 535i, it is essential to understand the overall context of the BMW 5 Series. As a mid-size luxury saloon, the 5 Series sits comfortably between the smaller 3 Series and the more extensive 7 Series. Known for its refined balance of performance, luxury, and comfort, the 5 Series is a highly respected vehicle in the BMW lineup.
The 528i and 535i are part of the F10 generation of the BMW 5 Series, produced between 2010 and 2017. The two vehicles share much of the same exterior and interior design language, with differences primarily coming from their engine choices and related performance specifications.
Engine Specifications and Performance
One of the primary differences between the BMW 528i and 535i is their engine configurations. Let’s start by exploring the engine options for both models.
BMW 528i: Engine Specifications
The 528i has a 2.0-litre, 4-cylinder turbocharged engine, part of BMW’s highly regarded “TwinPower Turbo” engine family. This engine can produce around 241 horsepower (hp) and 258 lb-ft of torque. With such a power output, the 528i delivers a strong and efficient driving experience, combining solid performance with better fuel economy compared to more powerful models.
Performance-wise, the 528i can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph (0-100 km/h) in approximately 6.2 seconds. While not the quickest in the 5 Series lineup, this model offers sufficient power for most drivers seeking a balance between speed and comfort. The 528i also benefits from a relatively low curb weight, which enhances fuel efficiency and handling.
BMW 535i: Engine Specifications
The 535i, on the other hand, comes with a 3.0-litre, 6-cylinder turbocharged engine, which delivers significantly more power. This engine produces around 302 hp and 295 lb-ft of torque, allowing the 535i to provide a more dynamic and exhilarating driving experience. With more power under the bonnet, the 535i accelerates from 0 to 60 mph (0-100 km/h) in about 5.7 seconds, making it noticeably quicker than the 528i.
The additional power in the 535i contributes to a more engaging performance, especially in situations where speed and responsiveness are key, such as overtaking or driving on winding roads. The 535i’s six-cylinder engine provides a smoother and more refined performance than the 528i’s four-cylinder option, making it the choice for those looking for more power and luxury.
Fuel Efficiency
The BMW 528i features a smaller engine, so it is generally more fuel-efficient than the 535i. Here’s a breakdown of the fuel economy for both models:
- BMW 528i: The 528i achieves an average fuel economy of around 24 mpg in the city and 34 mpg on the highway, offering a combined figure of 28 mpg.
- BMW 535i: The 535i, with its larger engine, achieves a lower fuel economy, typically around 20 mpg in the city and 30 mpg on the highway, with a combined average of 24 mpg.
While the 535i offers more power, it does come at the expense of fuel efficiency. For those prioritising fuel economy, the 528i would be the better option, while the 535i appeals to those who prefer a more powerful engine but are willing to accept slightly higher fuel consumption.
Driving Dynamics and Handling
The 528i and 535i feature BMW’s renowned rear-wheel-drive platform, with an all-wheel-drive option available for both models (xDrive). This layout provides excellent handling and stability, particularly in challenging driving conditions like wet or snowy weather.
Both models share the same architecture regarding suspension and chassis tuning, with double-wishbone front and multi-link rear suspensions. However, the 535i’s more powerful engine and larger tyres offer slightly sharper handling characteristics, particularly in more aggressive driving scenarios. Both vehicles benefit from precise steering and a balanced feel, a hallmark of BMW’s driving philosophy.
For those who prefer a sportier driving experience, the 535i, with its more powerful engine, might be more appealing. However, the 528i still delivers a satisfying drive with excellent ride quality, making it a great choice for those who want a comfortable and engaging ride without sacrificing luxury.
Interior and Features
The BMW 528i and 535i are luxury saloons with various high-end materials and features, reflecting their status. Both models offer a premium feel with leather upholstery, wood or metal trim, and high-quality finishes. The cabin is spacious and comfortable, with ample room for both front and rear passengers.
Infotainment System
Both models are equipped with BMW’s iDrive infotainment system, considered one of the most intuitive systems at the time of the F10 generation’s release. The system has an 8.8-inch display, a rotary controller, and a menu structure, allowing easy access to navigation, entertainment, and communication features. Both models also have Bluetooth connectivity, USB ports, and options for a premium sound system, such as Harman Kardon audio.
Technology and Safety Features
In terms of technology, both the 528i and 535i come with a suite of standard safety features, including stability and traction control, multiple airbags, and advanced driver assistance systems like lane-departure warning, front-collision warning, and adaptive cruise control.
The 535i has more standard features and options than the 528i, including additional luxury upgrades such as a larger touch screen, a head-up display, and a more advanced parking assistance system. These added options make the 535i stand out for buyers looking for the latest in technology and convenience.
Pricing and Value
When comparing the price of the BMW 528i and 535i, the 528i is the more affordable. At the time of their release, the starting price of the 528i was generally lower than that of the 535i, with the latter being positioned as a more premium model due to its higher-performance engine and additional luxury features.
While the 535i offers more power and a few additional features, the 528i remains a strong value proposition, especially for buyers looking for a well-rounded vehicle that balances performance with affordability. The 528i may be the better choice for budget-conscious people who still want to enjoy the high-quality driving experience that the 5 Series offers.
Reliability and Maintenance Costs
BMWs are known for their excellent build quality and reliability; the 528i and 535i are no exception. However, like all luxury cars, maintenance and repair costs can be higher than those of mainstream brands. The 535i, with its larger engine and more advanced technology, may incur slightly higher maintenance costs over time, especially as the vehicle ages.
Owners of the 528i can generally expect lower maintenance costs, as the smaller engine tends to be less complex. However, as with any BMW, regular maintenance is crucial to running the car smoothly.
Which One Should You Choose?
The decision between the BMW 528i and 535i largely depends on your priorities as a driver.
- BMW 528i: If you want a more fuel-efficient option that balances performance and luxury, the 528i is an excellent choice. It offers a comfortable ride, a refined driving experience, and a strong fuel economy, making it a fantastic option for those who do a lot of highway driving or want a more practical luxury saloon.
- BMW 535i: If performance and power are your primary concerns, the 535i is the superior option. Its more powerful 6-cylinder engine provides quicker acceleration and a more engaging driving experience. The 535i is perfect for those who enjoy dynamic driving and want a more refined luxury saloon.
Ultimately, both models offer a premium experience, with the choice regarding your personal preferences regarding performance, features, and budget.
Conclusion: BMW 528i vs 535i
The BMW 528i and 535i represent excellent choices in the mid-size luxury saloon market, each offering its distinct strengths. Whether you opt for the more efficient 528i or the performance-oriented 535i, both models promise the driving pleasure and sophistication that BMW is known for. Choosing between them depends on whether you prioritise performance or value, but in either case, you’re getting a luxurious and enjoyable vehicle.
FAQs
What is the main difference between the BMW 528i and 535i?
The primary difference between the BMW 528i and 535i lies in their engine configurations. The 528i features a 2.0-litre, 4-cylinder turbocharged engine producing 241 hp, while the 535i is equipped with a 3.0-litre, 6-cylinder turbocharged engine generating 302 hp. The 535i offers better performance and acceleration, but the 528i is more fuel-efficient.
Which BMW model is more fuel-efficient, the 528i or the 535i?
The BMW 528i is more fuel-efficient than the 535i. The 528i averages around 24 mpg in the city and 34 mpg on the highway, while the 535i achieves around 20 mpg in the city and 30 mpg on the highway. This makes the 528i a better choice for those prioritising fuel economy.
How fast is the BMW 528i compared to the BMW 535i?
The BMW 535i is faster than the 528i. The 535i can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph (0-100 km/h) in about 5.7 seconds, while the 528i takes approximately 6.2 seconds. The 535i’s more powerful engine provides quicker acceleration and a more dynamic driving experience.
Which BMW model offers better handling, the 528i or the 535i?
While both the 528i and 535i offer excellent handling due to BMW’s rear-wheel-drive platform, the 535i, with its more powerful engine and slightly larger tyres, tends to offer sharper handling, particularly in more aggressive driving scenarios. However, both vehicles deliver a well-balanced and precise driving experience.