The Subaru Legacy and Impreza have long been popular choices among car enthusiasts, offering a blend of performance, reliability, and versatility. Both models have their own unique strengths and appeal to different drivers.
In this article, we will compare and contrast the Subaru Legacy vs Impreza, examining their key features, performance, fuel efficiency, and overall value. Whether you’re a family-oriented driver or an adventure seeker, this comparison will help you determine which Subaru model is the best fit for your needs.
From their spacious interiors and advanced safety features to their off-road capabilities and fuel efficiency, the Legacy and Impreza offer a compelling package for drivers seeking a reliable and enjoyable vehicle. Let’s dive into the details and see which Subaru model comes out on top.
Table of Contents
Stretching Out or Snuggled In? Legacy vs. Impreza: A Tale of Two Sizes
Choosing the right car often boils down to space – how much room you need inside and how much presence it commands on the road. The Subaru Legacy and Impreza, while both offering the marque’s signature all-wheel-drive confidence, cater to different space requirements. Let’s delve into their dimensional differences to help you find the perfect fit.
Exterior Dimensions: A Matter of Footprint
The Subaru Legacy presents a more substantial footprint than the Impreza. In its latest iteration, the Legacy stretches to approximately 4.8 metres in length, compared to the Impreza’s more compact frame at roughly 4.5 metres. This difference is noticeable, giving the Legacy a more elongated and imposing presence on the road.
Width-wise, the Legacy typically measures around 1.8 metres, a touch broader than the Impreza’s approximately 1.75 metres. This extra width translates to a more planted stance and potentially more shoulder room within the cabin. Finally, in height, the Legacy stands a bit taller, usually around 1.5 metres, compared to the Impreza’s slightly lower profile. This distinction further contributes to the Legacy’s more traditional saloon silhouette.
Interior Space: Room to Breathe
Inside, the dimensional differences translate into noticeable variations in passenger and cargo interior space. The Legacy’s longer wheelbase and overall larger dimensions create a more spacious cabin, particularly in the rear.
Rear passengers will appreciate the extra legroom offered in the Legacy, making longer journeys more comfortable. Headroom is also generally more generous in the Legacy, accommodating taller individuals with ease. Up front, both models offer comfortable seating, but the Legacy often provides a slightly more expansive feel, owing to its wider cabin.
Meanwhile, the Impreza, though smaller, isn’t cramped. It provides adequate space for four adults, making it suitable for daily commutes and shorter trips. However, for regularly carrying rear passengers or those prioritising maximum legroom, the Legacy’s more luxurious interior design is advantageous.
Cargo Capacity: Hauling Your Gear
Boot space is another key differentiator. The Legacy, being the larger vehicle, boasts a more substantial boot, typically offering around 428 litres of cargo capacity. This makes it ideal for families, frequent travellers, or anyone needing to transport larger items regularly.
The Impreza’s boot, while still practical, is naturally smaller, typically providing around 348 litres of space depending on the model year and configuration. It’s sufficient for everyday errands and smaller luggage, but the Legacy undoubtedly offers greater flexibility for larger hauling needs.
Ground Clearance: Navigating the Terrain
Ground clearance plays a crucial role in a vehicle’s ability to handle varied terrains. Whilst not designed for serious off-roading, both the Legacy and Impreza benefit from Subaru’s symmetrical all-wheel-drive system, providing excellent traction in challenging conditions.
However, there are subtle differences in their ground clearance. The Impreza generally offers slightly more ground clearance than the Legacy, making it marginally better suited for navigating unpaved roads or light off-road trails. This difference, however, is usually relatively small, typically ranging from a few millimetres to a centimetre, depending on the specific model year and trim.
The Legacy, with its lower centre of gravity, provides a more planted and stable feel on paved roads, prioritising on-road handling and comfort. Ultimately, neither model is designed for serious off-road adventures.
Their strength lies in providing all-weather confidence and stability, particularly in snowy or wet conditions, rather than tackling rugged terrain. Choosing between the two depends on individual priorities: the Legacy for those who value on-road composure or the Impreza for those who occasionally venture onto less-than-perfect surfaces.
Unleashing the Power Within: Legacy vs. Impreza Engine Options and Performance
Beyond their spatial differences, the Subaru Legacy and Impreza offer distinct performance characteristics, catering to varying driving styles and needs. From fuel-efficient daily drivers to exhilarating performance models, let’s explore the engine options and drivetrain technologies that set these two Subaru stalwarts apart.
Legacy Engine Options: Balanced Power and Efficiency
The Subaru Legacy typically offers a range of engine choices designed to balance performance with fuel efficiency. In recent models, the standard engine is often a 2.5-litre, four-cylinder Boxer engine, delivering around 182 horsepower and 176 lb-ft of torque.
This engine provides ample power for everyday driving, offering smooth acceleration and comfortable cruising. Fuel economy figures typically fall within the range of 30-35 mpg combined, depending on driving conditions and specific configurations.
Some Legacy models also offer a more powerful turbocharged engine option, such as a 2.4-litre turbocharged Boxer four-cylinder. This engine significantly boosts performance, generating approximately 260 horsepower and 277 lb-ft of torque. This option caters to those seeking a more spirited driving experience while still maintaining reasonable fuel efficiency in the mid-20s mpg combined.
Impreza Engine Options: From Practical to Performance-Oriented
With its engine options, the Subaru Impreza caters to a broader spectrum of driving preferences, ranging from efficient daily drivers to exhilarating performance variants. The standard Impreza models usually feature a 2.0-litre, four-cylinder Boxer engine, producing around 152 horsepower and 145 lb-ft of torque. This engine prioritises fuel efficiency, delivering combined mpg figures in the high 20s to low 30s, making it an economical choice for daily commutes.
However, the Impreza truly shines in its performance-oriented WRX and STI trims. The WRX boasts a turbocharged 2.4-litre Boxer engine, churning out an impressive 271 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque. This potent engine transforms the Impreza into a thrilling performance machine capable of exhilarating acceleration and agile handling. Fuel economy understandably dips slightly with this increased power, typically landing in the low- to mid-20s mpg combined.
For the ultimate in Impreza performance, the STI (Subaru Tecnica International) model takes things even further. Historically powered by a turbocharged 2.5-litre Boxer engine (although recent models have seen changes), the STI generates even more horsepower and torque, pushing performance boundaries even further. However, this higher-performance engine also comes at a higher fuel cost.
Transmission Options: Smooth Shifting or Engaging Control
Both Legacy and Impreza primarily utilise Subaru’s Lineartronic Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT). This transmission provides smooth and seamless gear changes, optimising fuel efficiency and contributing to a comfortable driving experience.
However, for those seeking a more engaging driving experience, the Impreza, particularly in its WRX trim, often offers a manual transmission option. This allows drivers to take full control of gear shifts, enhancing the connection between driver and machine. The availability of a manual transmission can vary depending on the specific model year and trim level, so it’s crucial to check the specifications for the desired configuration.
All-Wheel-Drive System: Confidence in Every Condition
Underpinning the performance of both the Legacy and Impreza is Subaru’s renowned symmetrical all-wheel-drive system. This system continuously distributes power to all four wheels, ensuring optimal traction and stability in various road conditions. Unlike traditional all-wheel-drive systems that react to wheel slippage, Subaru’s symmetrical system proactively distributes power, anticipating potential loss of traction.
This all-wheel-drive system isn’t just about tackling inclement weather; it also contributes to improved handling and stability in dry conditions. The even distribution of power enhances cornering grip and reduces the risk of understeer or oversteer, making both the Legacy and Impreza surefooted and predictable on winding roads.
Tech-Savvy and Comfortable: Legacy vs. Impreza Features and Technology
Modern cars are no longer just about getting from A to B; they are about the experience of the journey. Both the Subaru Legacy and Impreza offer a compelling blend of features and technology, enhancing both comfort and convenience. Let’s explore the infotainment systems, safety technologies, and comfort features that distinguish these popular Subaru models.
Infotainment Systems: Staying Connected on the Go
Both the Legacy and Impreza offer modern infotainment systems designed to keep you connected and entertained on the road. Typically, both models feature touchscreen displays, providing intuitive access to various functions.
Screen sizes can vary depending on the trim level, with higher trims often boasting larger, more sophisticated displays. Both models generally support Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, allowing seamless integration with your smartphone for navigation, music streaming, and hands-free calling.
In terms of navigation, both the Legacy and Impreza offer integrated navigation systems on higher trim levels. These systems provide turn-by-turn directions, real-time traffic updates, and points-of-interest information. Even without the integrated navigation, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto effectively provide navigation functionality via familiar smartphone apps.
Safety Features: Prioritising Peace of Mind
Subaru prioritises safety, and both the Legacy and Impreza come equipped with a suite of advanced safety technologies. Subaru’s EyeSight driver assist system is a key feature, often standard on many trims. This system utilises stereo cameras to monitor the road ahead, providing features like adaptive cruise control, pre-collision braking, lane departure warning, and lane keep assist.
Furthermore, both models typically offer blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and automatic high-beam assist. Blind-spot monitoring alerts drivers to vehicles in their blind spots, aiding safe lane changes. A rear cross-traffic alert warns of approaching vehicles when reversing out of a parking space. Automatic high-beam assist automatically switches between high and low beams, optimising visibility without dazzling oncoming drivers.
Weighing the Investment: Subaru Legacy vs Impreza—Price and Value
Choosing between the Subaru Legacy and Impreza involves more than just comparing features and performance; it requires careful consideration of price and long-term value. Both models offer compelling value propositions, but understanding their respective pricing structures and potential resale values can help you make a financially sound decision. Let’s delve into the cost considerations of owning a Legacy or Impreza.
Starting MSRP and Trim Levels: Finding Your Fit
Both Legacy and Impreza offer a range of trim levels, each with its own set of features and corresponding price points. Typically, the Impreza starts at a lower MSRP than the Legacy, making it a more accessible entry point into the Subaru family.
Entry-level Impreza trims provide a solid foundation of features, including all-wheel drive, a user-friendly infotainment system, and essential safety technologies. As you move up the trim levels, additional features like upgraded infotainment systems, leather upholstery, and advanced driver-assist technologies become available, naturally increasing the price.
The Legacy, positioned as a more premium offering, typically starts at a higher MSRP than the Impreza. Its base trim already includes a more comprehensive set of features, often surpassing the entry-level Impreza in terms of standard equipment. Higher Legacy trims offer even more luxurious amenities, such as premium leather upholstery, larger touchscreen displays, and advanced safety systems.
Resale Value: Holding Their Worth
Subaru vehicles are generally known for their strong resale value, and both the Legacy and Impreza benefit from this reputation. Several factors contribute to their robust resale values, including Subaru’s reputation for reliability, the popularity of all-wheel drive, and the enduring appeal of both models.
Historically, the Impreza, particularly the WRX and STI performance variants, has demonstrated exceptional resale value, often retaining a significant percentage of its original MSRP even after several years of ownership.
The Legacy also holds its value well, though perhaps not quite as strongly as the Impreza. This is partly due to the Legacy’s position in the more competitive midsize saloon segment, where depreciation rates tend to be slightly higher. Nevertheless, both models offer reassuring resale prospects, making them smart long-term investments.
Long-Term Ownership Costs: Beyond the Sticker Price
Beyond the initial purchase price, it’s crucial to consider long-term ownership costs. These include fuel, insurance premiums, maintenance, and potential repair costs. As discussed earlier, the Impreza generally offers a slight advantage in fuel economy, potentially resulting in lower fuel costs over time. Insurance premiums can vary depending on driving history, location, and the specific model and trim level.
Maintenance costs are generally comparable between the two models, with both benefiting from Subaru’s reputation for reliability. However, budgeting for routine maintenance is always wise, including oil changes, tyre rotations, and brake replacements. Furthermore, researching potential repair costs and considering an extended warranty can provide peace of mind and protect against unexpected expenses.
Depreciation: The Gradual Decline
Depreciation is an inevitable aspect of car ownership. All cars lose value over time, and the depreciation rate can vary depending on several factors, including the make and model, mileage, condition, and market trends.
As mentioned earlier, both the Legacy and Impreza hold relatively good values compared to other vehicles in their respective segments. However, understanding the typical depreciation curve for each model can help you make informed decisions about when to buy or sell.
Behind the Wheel: Comparing the Legacy and Impreza Driving Experiences
The true test of any car lies in the driving experience. Both the Subaru Legacy and Impreza offer distinct driving dynamics, catering to different preferences and priorities. From comfortable cruising to exhilarating performance, let’s explore what it’s like to get behind the wheel of these two compelling Subaru models.
Legacy Driving Experience: Refined and Composed
The Subaru Legacy delivers a refined and composed driving experience, prioritising comfort and stability. Its suspension system effectively absorbs road imperfections, providing a smooth and comfortable ride, even on less-than-perfect surfaces. The cabin remains quiet and well-insulated from road noise, creating a serene and relaxing environment for drivers and passengers.
Thanks to Subaru’s symmetrical all-wheel-drive system, handling is predictable and secure. The Legacy feels planted and confident in corners, inspiring driver confidence. Steering is precise and responsive, allowing for effortless manoeuvrability in urban environments and on winding country roads. Overall, the Legacy offers a balanced and comfortable driving experience, well-suited for long journeys and daily commutes. It’s not designed for outright performance but prioritises a smooth, refined, and confident ride.
Impreza Driving Experience: Versatile and Engaging
The standard Impreza offers a more engaging driving experience than the Legacy. It has a sportier edge while still maintaining a good level of everyday comfort. Its suspension is tuned for a slightly firmer ride, providing better handling and responsiveness. While still comfortable for daily driving, the Impreza offers a more connected feel to the road, allowing drivers to feel more involved in the experience.
Steering is sharp and precise, making the Impreza nimble and agile in urban environments. Body roll is well-controlled, contributing to confident cornering. The Impreza’s all-wheel-drive system provides excellent traction and stability, enhancing its dynamic capabilities. While not a full-blown performance car, the standard Impreza offers a satisfying balance of comfort and sportiness, appealing to drivers who enjoy a more engaging driving experience.
WRX/STI: Unleashing the Inner Racer
The Impreza WRX and STI elevate the driving experience to a new level. These performance-oriented variants transform the Impreza into a true driver’s car, capable of exhilarating acceleration and thrilling handling. The turbocharged engines provide a power surge, delivering impressive acceleration and a satisfyingly sporty exhaust note.
The WRX and STI feature significantly upgraded suspension systems tuned for maximum performance. Handling is sharp and responsive, with minimal body roll and exceptional grip. The all-wheel-drive system is further enhanced in these models, providing even greater traction and stability and allowing drivers to confidently push the limits. The steering is precise and communicative, providing excellent feedback to the driver.
The driving experience in the WRX and STI is undeniably more raw and visceral than the standard Impreza or Legacy. These models are designed for driving enthusiasts who crave performance and relish the thrill of pushing a car to its limits. However, this heightened performance comes at the expense of some ride comfort. The firmer suspensions and performance-oriented tyres can make the ride less forgiving on rough roads.
Conclusion
The Subaru Legacy and Impreza, while sharing the brand’s commitment to all-wheel-drive capability and safety, offer distinct driving experiences and cater to different needs and priorities. Take your time to examine their size and space, performance, fuel efficiency, features, and overall value proposition. Choosing the right model ultimately comes down to aligning these factors with your individual lifestyle and requirements.