The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ, two nearly identical sports cars jointly developed by Toyota and Subaru, have captivated driving enthusiasts since their debut in 2012. These twin coupes share a platform and mechanical components, yet each possesses distinct characteristics that can sway prospective buyers one way or the other. At their core, the 86 and BRZ are designed to deliver a pure, unfiltered driving experience. Their focus on lightweight construction, balanced handling, and rear-wheel-drive dynamics harks back to classic sports cars, providing a refreshing alternative to the increasingly complex and powerful vehicles dominating today’s market.
Despite their similarities, subtle differences in design, performance tuning, and brand identity give each car a unique flavour. The Toyota 86 is often lauded for its slightly more aggressive aesthetics and playful driving dynamics, while the Subaru BRZ is praised for its refined handling and stability. This article delves into a detailed comparison of the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ, examining their design, performance, interior, technology, and overall driving experience to help potential buyers decide which of these remarkable sports cars best aligns with their preferences and driving style.
Whether you’re an enthusiast seeking a weekend track toy or someone looking for an engaging daily driver, understanding the nuances between the 86 and BRZ is crucial in making an informed decision.
Table of Contents
Design and Aesthetics Of Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ are sports car twins, but even twins have their own flair. Let’s see how their designs differentiate:
Exterior Design
At first glance, the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ appear virtually identical. Both vehicles feature a sleek, low-slung profile with a long bonnet and a short rear deck, emphasising their rear-wheel-drive layout. The styling is sporty and aggressive, with sharp lines and aerodynamic shapes that convey a sense of speed even when the cars are stationary.
However, there are subtle differences. The front fascias of the two cars are distinct, with the Toyota 86 sporting a more angular, aggressive front grille and headlight design compared to the slightly more rounded and conservative look of the BRZ. These differences are minor but crucial for buyers who prefer one aesthetic.
Interior Design
Inside, both cars offer a driver-focused cockpit with a low seating position, which enhances the feeling of being connected to the vehicle. The materials and build quality are commendable, with a mix of soft-touch surfaces and high-quality plastics. The seats are supportive, providing ample bolstering for spirited driving.
The interiors of the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ are almost identical, except for minor details like the steering wheel logo and some trim options. Both cars offer a straightforward, no-nonsense layout, prioritising functionality and driver engagement over luxury. This approach aligns with the cars’ sports car ethos, though it might seem spartan to those accustomed to more upscale interiors.
Performance and Handling
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ may be twins, but there could be whispers of individuality under the bonnet. Let’s delve into their performance and handling characteristics:
Engine and Transmission
Under the bonnet, the 86 and BRZ are powered by a 2.0-litre flat-four “boxer” engine developed by Subaru. This engine produces 205 horsepower and 156 lb-ft of torque, which might not seem like much in the era of turbocharged powerhouses. Still, it’s more than sufficient to deliver an exhilarating driving experience. The flat-four layout also contributes to the car’s low centre of gravity, enhancing its handling capabilities.
Both cars offer a choice of a six-speed manual or a six-speed automatic transmission. The manual gearbox is preferred for driving purists, providing a more engaging and immersive experience. While less engaging, the automatic transmission is still competent and features paddle shifters for manual control.
Handling and Dynamics
The real magic of the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ lies in their handling. Both cars are renowned for their balanced chassis, sharp steering, and agile handling. The rear-wheel-drive layout, combined with the low centre of gravity, allows for precise and responsive handling, making these cars a joy to drive on twisty roads or a track.
The suspension setup is firm but not overly harsh, striking a good balance between comfort and performance. The limited-slip differential, standard on both models, further enhances the driving experience by ensuring power is effectively distributed to the rear wheels, aiding traction and stability during spirited driving.
While both cars offer similar driving dynamics, subtle tuning differences give each a unique character. The Toyota 86 is often described as having a more playful, tail-happy nature, making it easier to induce oversteer. The Subaru BRZ, on the other hand, is tuned for slightly more stability, offering a more neutral handling balance. These differences are minor but can be felt by experienced drivers, potentially influencing their preferences.
Interior and Technology
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ may be close cousins under the bonnet, but do their interiors reflect the same story? Let’s unwrap the similarities and subtle distinctions in their cabins:
Comfort and Space
Despite their compact dimensions, the 86 and BRZ offer a reasonably comfortable cabin for front-seat occupants. The seats are well-bolstered and supportive, ideal for long drives or track days. However, the rear seats are more symbolic than practical, offering minimal space suitable only for small children or extra luggage.
As expected from a sports car, the boot space is modest but can accommodate a couple of small bags or groceries. For those needing more storage, the rear seats can be folded to expand the cargo area.
Infotainment and Connectivity
In terms of technology, both the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ have seen improvements over the years. The latest models feature updated infotainment systems with touchscreen interfaces, offering connectivity options like Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. While these systems are functional and intuitive, they might not be as advanced or feature-rich as those in some competitors or higher-end models.
The sound systems in both cars are decent, but audiophiles might find them lacking compared to more premium offerings. However, these cars’ primary focus is driving engagement, and the available technology is adequate for most needs.
Safety and Reliability
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ might be known for their thrilling performance, but safety and reliability are crucial factors, too. Let’s explore how these twins stack up in these crucial areas:
Safety Features
Safety is an important consideration, even for sports cars. The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ have safety features, including multiple airbags, stability, and traction control. Recent models have also introduced advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), such as adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning, and automatic emergency braking.
These features enhance the safety profile of both cars, making them suitable for everyday driving and spirited weekend outings. It’s worth noting that while the ADAS technologies are a welcome addition, they are not as comprehensive or advanced as those found in more modern vehicles.
Reliability and Maintenance
Toyota and Subaru have solid reputations for reliability, and the 86 and BRZ are no exceptions. Owners generally report high satisfaction with these cars’ durability and longevity. Routine maintenance is straightforward and inexpensive, thanks to the relatively simple mechanical layout and the wide availability of parts.
It’s also worth noting that both Toyota and Subaru offer comprehensive warranties and excellent customer service, further enhancing the ownership experience. Regular servicing at authorised dealerships ensures that the cars remain in top condition and retain their value over time.
Driving Experience
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ may be twins separated at birth, but how do they feel when you slip behind the wheel? Let’s delve into the heart of the driving experience for each car:
Everyday Usability
While the 86 and BRZ are designed for driving enthusiasts, they are also practical enough for daily use. The ride quality, though firm, is manageable for regular commuting, and the compact dimensions make them easy to manoeuvre in urban environments. Fuel economy is respectable for a sports car, with both models achieving around 30 miles per gallon on the highway.
While not luxurious, the interiors are comfortable and offer sufficient amenities for everyday driving. Features like automatic climate control, heated seats, and a reasonably user-friendly infotainment system contribute to a pleasant driving experience.
Performance Driving
The 86 and BRZ genuinely shine on twisty roads and racetracks. Their precise steering, balanced chassis, and responsive handling make them incredibly engaging to drive. While not overly powerful, the naturally aspirated engine delivers a linear power curve and a satisfying exhaust note, enhancing the overall driving experience.
The manual transmission, in particular, is a joy to use, with short, crisp throws and a well-weighted clutch. While less engaging, the automatic transmission is competent and features sports modes that adjust the shift points for more aggressive driving.
The lightweight construction and rear-wheel-drive layout allow for playful dynamics, with the ability to induce oversteer and enjoy controlled drifts. These characteristics make both cars ideal for track days or spirited drives on winding roads.
Ownership Costs and Value
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ may be thrilling twins on the road, but how do they stack up when it comes to ownership costs and overall value? Let’s analyse the factors that might impact your wallet in the long run.
Pricing
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ are competitively priced and offer a lot of performance for the money. Their starting prices are similar, with the Toyota 86 typically being slightly more affordable by a small margin. However, the price difference is minimal and usually not a deciding factor for most buyers.
Depreciation
Both cars hold their value relatively well compared to other sports cars. Their reputation for reliability and a strong following of enthusiasts ensures they remain desirable in the used car market. Regular maintenance and care can further enhance their resale value.
Running Costs
Running costs for the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ are reasonable for sports cars. The fuel economy is decent, and insurance premiums are generally affordable. Routine maintenance and servicing costs are also manageable, thanks to the cars’ straightforward mechanical layout and parts availability.
Conclusion
The Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ are excellent sports cars with an engaging driving experience, impressive handling, and practical usability. While they are nearly identical in many respects, subtle differences in design, tuning, and branding can influence a buyer’s decision.
The Toyota 86 might appeal more to those who prefer its slightly more aggressive styling and playful handling characteristics. On the other hand, the Subaru BRZ could attract buyers who favour its marginally more stable handling and the Subaru brand.
Ultimately, the choice between the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ is a personal preference. Both cars deliver an exhilarating driving experience and represent excellent value for money in the sports car segment. Whether you choose the Toyota 86 or the Subaru BRZ, you can enjoy a car that prioritises driving pleasure and offers a rewarding ownership experience.