When comparing the Subaru BRZ to the Scion FR-S, several aspects come into play, including exterior styling, interior design, engine power and fuel efficiency, handling and driving experience, and safety features.
Table of Contents
How are Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S related to Toyota?
The Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S are mechanically identical cars developed in a joint venture between Subaru and Toyota. They are both rear-wheel-drive sports cars with a 2.0-litre boxer engine. Subaru marketed the BRZ, while Scion, Toyota’s youth-oriented brand, sold the FR-S.
Scion was discontinued in 2016, and the FR-S was rebranded as the Toyota 86. So, as of today, the Subaru BRZ and Toyota 86 are essentially the same car, with only minor cosmetic differences.
Subaru and Toyota formed the joint venture because they wanted to create an affordable, rear-wheel-drive sports car that was fun to drive and practical. By working together, they were able to share development costs and resources.
The BRZ and 86 have been praised for their excellent handling and fun-to-drive nature. They are also relatively affordable, making them popular with enthusiasts.
Here is a table summarising the relationship between the Subaru BRZ, Scion FR-S, and Toyota 86:
| Car | Manufacturer | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Subaru BRZ | Subaru | 2012-present |
| Scion FR-S | Scion | 2012-2016 |
| Toyota 86 | Toyota | 2012-2016, 2017-present |
What Does FR-S Stand For?
FR-S is an acronym that reflects the car’s fundamental design philosophy:
- F: Front-engine
- R: Rear-wheel drive
- S: Sport
This naming underscores the FR-S’s focus on driving engagement: the engine is placed in the front, power is delivered to the rear wheels, and the car’s overall setup is optimised for spirited, sporty driving.
What Engine Is in the FR-S?
Under the bonnet, the Scion FR-S shares the same 2.0-litre “boxer” four-cylinder engine co-developed by Toyota and Subaru. This flat, horizontally opposed engine design gives the car a low centre of gravity, significantly improving handling. Depending on the model year and transmission, horsepower generally ranges from about 200 hp to 228 hp for later updates.
Brand Lineage
- Scion: The FR-S was initially released under Toyota’s Scion brand (2012–2016) as a youth-oriented offering in North America.
- Collaboration with Subaru: The FR-S is essentially a sibling to the Subaru BRZ, sharing nearly all mechanical components and dimensions.
- Transition to Toyota 86: When Toyota discontinued the Scion brand in 2016, the FR-S was rebranded as the Toyota 86 in most global markets.
By understanding the meaning behind “FR-S” and the car’s engineering partnership, enthusiasts can appreciate why it’s such a balanced and affordable sports car. Its front-engine, rear-wheel-drive layout and the boxer engine deliver an engaging driving experience that has garnered a loyal following among automotive fans.
Subaru BRZ vs Scion FR-S: The Ultimate Comparison
The “Subaru BRZ vs Scion FR-S” debate is captivating in the realm of affordable sports cars. Both vehicles were born from a collaboration between Subaru and Toyota, making them siblings in speed and spirit, yet each brings a unique flavour to the asphalt.
This comparison aims to delve into the nuances that set them apart, from the roar of the engines to the curve-hugging performance, and determine which of these automotive marvels holds the edge in a head-to-head matchup. Whether you’re a die-hard enthusiast or a curious onlooker, the Subaru BRZ vs Scion FR-S comparison is bound to rev up your interest.
Detailed Features
Exterior Styling
Regarding exterior design, the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S present a fascinating study in nuanced automotive aesthetics. Both sport the same sleek, low-slung profile that is the hallmark of a modern sports coupe, but there are subtle distinctions to sway potential buyers.
The BRZ flaunts a slightly more aggressive front fascia with its hawk-eye headlights and a pronounced Subaru badge, signalling a bolder approach to the road ahead. In contrast, the FR-S opts for more understated elegance with a mesh grille and streamlined headlights, emphasising its Toyota heritage of simplicity and efficiency. Both cars’ side vents and alloy wheels are similar yet uniquely branded to appeal to their respective followers.
While their silhouettes are nearly identical, reflecting their shared platform, it’s the small details in the grille patterns, badging, and headlight design where the BRZ and FR-S diverge, each offering a different aesthetic flavour to the same sports car recipe.
Interior Design
Regarding the interior design of the Subaru BRZ vs Scion FR-S, both coupes offer a driver-focused cabin with a blend of sportiness and simplicity. The BRZ boasts a slightly more refined interior with soft-touch materials and a cohesive design language that speaks to its Subaru heritage. It offers supportive seats with ample bolstering to keep you secure during spirited driving.
On the other hand, the Scion FR-S opts for a more minimalist approach, aligning with its ethos of functional simplicity. Its straightforward dashboard layout emphasizes essential controls, reflecting its no-frills sports car philosophy.
Both interiors are tailored for driving enthusiasts, featuring precise instrumentation, a low seating position, and a steering wheel that begs to be gripped on winding roads. While the BRZ may edge out with more elegance, the FR-S stays true to a raw, performance-tuned environment.
Engine Power and Fuel Efficiency
Regarding engine power and fuel efficiency, the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S have their own merits.
| Car Model | Engine Power | Fuel Efficiency |
|---|---|---|
| Subaru BRZ | The Subaru BRZ, with its base engine, provides a solid 200 horsepower. However, with the 6-speed automatic transmission, the power drops to 200 horsepower and 151 lb-ft of torque. When running at 7,000 rpm, the engine power of the Subaru BRZ ramps up to 228 hp, offering a smoother driving experience. | Like its Subaru counterpart, the Scion FR-S operates on premium unleaded 98 RON fuel. The same engine and transmissions match the Subaru BRZ in achieving 21 mpg in fuel efficiency. |
| Scion FR-S | The Subaru BRZ runs on premium unleaded 98 RON fuel. Manual transmission achieves 21 mpg in fuel efficiency. The fuel economy improves to 22 mpg in the city and 30 mpg on the highway, providing a combined mpg of 25. | Like its Subaru counterpart, the Scion FR-S operates on premium unleaded 98 RON fuel. The same engine and transmissions match the Subaru BRZ, achieving 21 mpg in fuel efficiency. |
These figures highlight the similarities between the two models regarding power and fuel efficiency. While they have the same engine and transmissions, the Subaru BRZ seems to have a slight edge regarding smoother performance and fuel economy. However, individual driving styles and preferences could significantly influence these outcomes.
Handling and Driving Experience
While sharing a common platform and many features, the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S show subtle differences in handling and driving experience. Both cars prioritise a nimble and responsive feel on the road, thanks to their lightweight construction and low centre of gravity.
However, the BRZ, with its updated suspension tuning, tends to lean slightly towards a sportier edge. It offers a bit more precise steering and enhanced cornering grip, making it an excellent choice for enthusiasts seeking an engaging driving experience.
On the other hand, the Scion FR-S, with its balanced and predictable handling, provides a more accessible feel for drivers exploring the joys of spirited driving. Whether you lean towards the BRZ’s sharpness or the FR-S’s approachability, both cars deliver an exhilarating and enjoyable ride, making them standout options in affordable sports cars.
Safety
When examining the safety aspects of the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S, it’s important to note that both vehicles were engineered with a strong focus on passenger protection. Both cars have a comprehensive suite of safety features, including advanced airbag systems, stability control, and anti-lock braking systems. Structurally, they benefit from using high-tensile steel in critical areas designed to withstand impacts.
The BRZ and FR-S have both been subjected to rigorous crash testing, with results showing commendable protection in various collision scenarios. However, the Subaru BRZ edges forward slightly with its available Subaru EyeSight Driver Assist Technology in newer models, which includes features like pre-collision braking and lane departure warning.
While the Scion FR-S offers a robust safety package, it lacks Subaru’s proprietary driver-assist system. Ultimately, both cars meet high safety standards, but the Subaru BRZ offers more active safety technology, which might appeal to safety-conscious drivers.
Reliability & Maintenance
The Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S (later rebranded as the Toyota 86) have proven relatively robust choices regarding long-term dependability. Their lightweight platform and 2.0-litre boxer engine, developed collaboratively by Subaru and Toyota, form a solid foundation that tends to hold up well with routine care.
Owners often report trouble-free driving past 100,000 miles (160,000 km) provided that regular oil changes, fluid checks, and factory-recommended servicing are followed. The boxer engine’s unique layout requires careful attention to oil levels and spark plug changes, but these are predictable maintenance points rather than unexpected expenses.
One area to monitor is wear on suspension components due to the firm, performance-oriented setup, which can accelerate bushing or shock absorber wear if you frequently encounter rough roads. Clutch longevity in manual-transmission models depends heavily on driving style, as spirited driving can cause faster deterioration. A consistent service schedule and prompt resolution of minor issues—such as oil leaks or unusual engine noises—will keep the BRZ and FR-S running reliably for years.
Cost & Resale Value
The cost of ownership for either model is generally manageable, especially for enthusiasts seeking an affordable rear-wheel-drive sports car. Fuel efficiency hovers around the mid-20s in miles per gallon, and both vehicles require premium unleaded (98 RON) to perform at their best. Insurance premiums vary by location and driver history, but they tend to be moderate compared to higher-powered sports coupes. Given the ongoing production of the Subaru BRZ and Toyota 86, parts remain readily available, so future maintenance should not be challenging.
Resale values for well-maintained BRZ and FR-S models have historically been buoyed by a dedicated community of enthusiasts. Subaru’s longstanding reputation for durability can give the BRZ a slight edge in specific markets. Yet, the FR-S, which is closely related to Toyota, also benefits from a trusted brand image.
Regardless of badge, a documented maintenance history and minimal modifications help command higher resale prices, as prospective buyers often look for cars that have been cared for rather than heavily tuned or driven hard on the track.
How to Choose the Right Vehicle
The Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S are mechanically identical cars, so the decision of which one to choose ultimately comes down to personal preference. Here are a few things to consider when making your decision:
Consider Your Budget
When choosing between the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S, it’s essential to consider your budget. Both cars offer affordable options for car lovers looking for cost-effective choices. These models are available at various prices that fit different budgets, ensuring value for money.
By evaluating your budget and comparing prices, you can identify the right vehicle that meets your needs without breaking the bank. Whether you’re looking for fuel-efficiency or stylish design, budget-friendly options are available in the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S lineup.
Evaluate Vehicle Features and Performance
When choosing between the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S, evaluating their vehicle features and performance is important. Both cars have similar features and performance since they are essentially the same car with different badges.
They both offer a sporty design, powerful engines, and excellent handling. The BRZ is particularly praised for its smooth handling and precise steering. So, if you’re looking for a sports car that offers great performance and exciting features, the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S are fantastic options.
Compare Safety Ratings
The Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S are both highly rated for safety. They have both received the IIHS Top Safety Pick rating, which means they meet rigorous crashworthiness and avoidance standards.
To earn this distinction, a car must score well in various tests conducted by the IIHS and offer advanced safety features like frontal crash alert or crash-prevention systems. So, whether you choose the Subaru BRZ or Scion FR-S, you can feel confident knowing that these cars will prioritise your safety on the road.
FAQs
Can I Interchange Parts Between a Subaru BRZ and a Scion FRS?
Yes, most parts are interchangeable between the two models due to their shared platform. This allows for greater availability of aftermarket upgrades or replacement components.
Does Either Car Have Better Resale Value – Subaru BRZ or Scion FRS?
It depends on various factors such as demand in your local market, vehicle condition, mileage driven, and maintenance history rather than just brand name. When determining resale value, listings for these models tend to be similar overall.
What Is the Difference Between the Subaru BRZ and Scion FRS?
The Subaru BRZ and Scion FRS are the same car, with only minor cosmetic differences. They were developed in collaboration between Subaru and Toyota but marketed under different brand names.
Are Scions still made?
No. Toyota discontinued the Scion brand in 2016. The popular Scion models were either rebranded as Toyotas (e.g., the Scion FR-S became the Toyota 86) or phased out entirely.
Why did Scion stop making cars?
Toyota initially launched Scion as a youth-focused brand, primarily for the US market. Over time, Toyota decided to consolidate Scion’s offerings under the main Toyota banner, concluding that it could more effectively serve customers by unifying all models under one name.
What engine does the Scion FR-S use?
The Scion FR-S is powered by a 2.0-litre horizontally opposed “boxer” four-cylinder engine, jointly developed by Toyota and Subaru. This layout helps lower the car’s centre of gravity for improved handling and sporty performance.
Overall, the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S (Toyota 86) are very similar cars with slight differences in weight and suspension. Both offer great performance, fuel efficiency, and stylish design.
Ultimately, choosing the right vehicle will depend on your preferences and needs. So, take into consideration your budget, evaluate the features and performance of each car, compare safety ratings, and choose the one that best suits you. Happy car hunting!